Chalk it up to moving or hoarding cleaning supplies — either way, I ended up with too much of everything under the kitchen sink. Following Jen’s advice to remove, minimize and wipe everything down before replacing, this job was quick and fulfilling:
I am beginning to remember how living in less than 1000 square feet means nesting bowls, suitcases, etc., whenever possible and never having duplicates open at the same time. And when in doubt, add yellow shelf paper. It makes any job seem happy.